Skip to main content

Autopay Payment Failed: Why It Happens and How to Resolve It

Jessica Lara
  • Updated

This article covers why an autopay charge fails in Finalsite Enrollment, what the system and the payer see when it does, and how to resolve each cause. Most autopay failures are resolved by the parent updating their payment method in the Parent Portal; a few require School or Support action.

💡Quick Answers

  • Why did an autopay payment fail? The most common causes are insufficient funds, a bank that revoked the autopay authorization, a closed bank account, or an expired or declined card.
  • What happens automatically when a payment fails? The charge is added back to the payer's ledger. If Retry Failed Autopay Payments is enabled, the payer gets an Autopay Failure Retry email and the system re-attempts once, 2 days later. If it fails again, or retry is off, autopay is turned off for that payer, and the payer gets an Autopay Failure email.
  • The error says "Invalid Account Number" or "Inactive Mandates." The bank revoked the autopay authorization. The parent must remove and re-add their payment method in the Parent Portal; updating the existing one will not work.
  • Can the school fix a failed autopay charge? No. The parent must update or re-add their payment method in the Parent Portal (Billing Management tab). The school can enable automatic retries and communicate with the family.
  • Is there a fee when a payment fails? If the failure is insufficient funds and your school passes on NSF fees, a fee (standard $25) posts on the date the payment failed. NSF fees are charged only on the first failure, not the retry.
  • Where does the parent update their payment method? Parent Portal > Billing Management tab.

In this Article

What Causes an Autopay Failure

Autopay withdraws a balance from the payer's saved payment method on their billing date. A charge fails when that payment method cannot be charged. The common causes:

  • Insufficient Funds: The bank account does not have enough to cover the charge. This is the most common ACH failure and may trigger an NSF fee.
  • Bank-revoked Authorization: After 6 months to a year of successful autopay, a bank can revoke the recurring-payment authorization (mandate). The failure shows an error such as Invalid Account Number or Inactive Mandates on the Payment History page. This is seen most often with PNC and Chase but can happen with any bank.
  • Closed Bank Account: The account was closed. This failure cannot be retried automatically.
  • Expired or Declined Card: For card-based autopay, the card expired or the issuer declined the charge.

What Happens when a Payment Fails

  1. The failed charge is added back to the payer's ledger. The chargeback posts on the original payment date.
  2. If Retry Failed Autopay Payments is enabled (Settings > Financial > Billing Setup), the payer receives an Autopay Failure Retry email with the retry date, and the system re-attempts the charge 2 days later.
    • If the retry succeeds, autopay stays on and the payer receives a Payment Received email.
    • If the retry fails, autopay is turned off and the payer receives an Autopay Failure email. Retries happen only once.
  3. Some failures cannot be retried at all, such as a closed bank account.
  4. If the failure is insufficient funds and your school passes on NSF fees, a fee (standard $25) posts on the date the payment failed. NSF is charged only on the first failure.

Resolve By Cause

  • Insufficient Funds: The parent confirms funds are available, then either waits for the automatic retry or makes a manual payment from the Parent Portal.
  • Invalid Account Number or Inactive Mandates (bank revoked authorization): The parent must remove and re-add the payment method in the Parent Portal (Billing Management tab). Updating the existing method will not work. The parent automatically receives a Payment Method Deactivated email directing them to do this. Because the bank initiated it, there is nothing Finalsite Enrollment or the school can do to prevent it.
  • Closed Bank Account: The charge cannot be retried. The parent must add a new payment method in the Parent Portal.
  • Expired or Declined Card: The parent updates the card or adds a new payment method in the Parent Portal.

What the Parent Needs To Do

  • Go to the Parent Portal > Billing Management tab.
  • For a revoked or closed account, remove the old payment method and add a new one. Do not just edit the existing one.
  • For insufficient funds, confirm funds are available and let the retry run, or make a manual payment.
  • Re-enable autopay if it was turned off after a second failure.

Note: ACH payments take 5 to 7 days to process, so a resolved payment will not clear instantly.

What the School Can Do

  • Enable Retry Failed Autopay Payments (Settings > Financial > Billing Setup; requires System Admin or Admin with Financial permission) so most failures re-attempt automatically.
  • Use the Accounts list page to filter autopay-enrolled families and email them directly.
  • Note that the school cannot re-add a parent's payment method for them; the parent must do that in the Parent Portal.
  • Note that NSF fees applied by the payment processor cannot be refunded to the school if you choose to waive them for a parent.

Contact Finalsite Support

If a payment keeps failing after the parent updates their payment method, or you need help with NSF fee setup, submit a request to Finalsite Support and include:

  • The affected payer or family. Name, and the student if relevant.
  • The exact failure error. For example, Invalid Account Number or Inactive Mandates.
  • The dates. The original payment date and the date it failed.
  • Retry status. Whether Retry Failed Autopay Payments is enabled.
  • NSF setup. Whether you want help setting up or adjusting NSF fee pass-through.

Additional Resources

Related articles

Comments

0 comments

Article is closed for comments.